« Back to blog

rational vs. romantic

This post has been in the incubator for awhile. The idea to write about marriage was one that came to me soon after I began hyphenated, but the post needed to marinate so that I could gather all my thoughts (I have many thoughts on this particular topic). So, on that note,... here it goes:

Kevin and I have been together a long time. We started dating when 'teen' was still a component of our age, if that's any indication. We've lived together for almost five years. We're committed to each other - we're in this for the long haul. For better or worse. But we're not married or engaged. 

In that context, the question posed to Kevin by an acquaintance in San Francisco, namely "Why haven't you made an honest woman out of her already?", is one that comes up often enough (although most people pose it with more tact).

My main answer to that question is another question: "What's the point?"

I don't intend to suggest that marriage has no meaning. For instance, I can see how marriage  would mean a lot to a gay couple in a jurisdiction where same-sex marriages are illegal. I can understand how marriage means a lot to a girl who grew up dreaming of her wedding day. I can see how marriage is important to those with strong religious views. But, I am not gay and I was more tomboy than little princess and I'm an atheist so, alas, marriage just isn't that important to me. 

And, perhaps counter-intuitively, the longer I'm with Kevin the more insignificant marriage seems. After being together this many years, we've gone through good and bad times together and we've grown together. Our bond is true. We both know what the answer would be if one of us were to propose, but I don't see the need for a wedding to prove something that we already know.

When the stats are thrown into the mix (over a third of all marriages in Canada and almost half of those in the United States end in divorce), marriage doesn't look any more compelling.

That said, I wish I could call Kevin my husband without lying. There is no English good word for a committed, long-term partnership. Common-law spouse is too legal and unromantic. Partner is too vague (business partner?). Trying to convey my relationship to Kevin to those who don't know us is challenging and, in certain circumstances, I'll refer to him as my husband just to make things easier. Despite wanting to call Kevin my husband, I don't think that semantics provide a good reason to get married.

Some of my friend have gotten married partly because it is the first step to starting a family. Second step: children. As it stands now (never say never?), Kevin and I are, borrowing a great acronym from Dervala, C.A.L.I. No kids in the picture. We're destined to be DINKS* as far as I can tell. If there's no plan for step 2, why pursue step 1?

Maybe I take marriage for granted. Or maybe I'm too rational and not one to let my heart win in a debate with my brain. The (albeit small) part of me that is romantic wants to get married. But, when my romantic fraction pipes up, my brain counters "what's the point?". I'll keep thinking about it and maybe one day I'll come up with a worthy answer. Either that, or my heart will catch my brain off-guard and take full advantage. 

As it stands today, I don't have plans to ask anyone to "save the date". My dad's probably happy to hear that since I won't be asking for the 50 bucks that he agreed to contribute to my wedding anytime soon.

*Double income, no kids.

Comments (8)

Jun 04, 2009
megan said...
Thanks for writing this, Arianne. I have had many of the same thoughts, from an atheist world view, to understanding the importance of the institution of marriage and freedom to partake for those who have been denied that freedom, to the lack of desire to have children and corresponding desire to simplify things through legal ties. Although currently sans "significant other" (how is that for a mouthful), my inclination has always been that I would not need to "legalize" my relationships through marriage. That being said, I never dreamed of the big white wedding, either...

I can never say never, though. I have friends who "legitimized" their long term relationship because one of them desperately needed healthcare. Be thankful that that is not even an issue that makes your list of reasons you would consider marriage. And in the same theme, when I had surgery not too long ago, my "domestic partner" was not allowed to be the person I listed as capable of making any emergency medical decisions that I was unable to make. He had no legal standing, so I had to list my parents... who live 5,000 miles from me (and as much as they love me, had no idea what my wishes were).

Matters of the heart should be just that, in my opinion. They are complicated enough on their own... but there sure are lots of ways to make them more so!

Jun 06, 2009
Christopher Batty said...
If your heart desires it, and your brain is ambivalent, then why not, really? Just think, you could become even more hyphenated. ;-)
Jun 08, 2009
Arianne said...
I'm glad I'm not alone in my views, Megan.

Christopher, The hassle of organizing a wedding may be one such reason! Also, I think that there's a legal maximum of two last names - I'd have to trade one in, give them both up, or stick with the status quo.

Jun 09, 2009
elaine said...
Like I said, as far as I can see, you and kevin are married, and I would go ahead and call him your mate, spouse, husband, life partner, whatever. In your hearts, you are married, and that's what counts. And being atheist really has nothing to do with it chosing a wedding or not, because being married before god is not conditional on having a weddings. Weddings are the religion/legal/cultural/celebratory side of things. Marriage is the long haul committment, and belief in god only helps if you can't hack your partner anymore and need other reasons to hang around in the marriage.
So, let's have a party, and celebrate you and kevin, and then you can 'honestly' (and legally after 2 years) say that you are married. I'll bring the cole slaw!
Jun 09, 2009
NirajK said...
I love Elaine's idea. We'll bring the nan, butter chicken and vegetarian curry :).
Jun 10, 2009
Arianne said...
I think I'll refer to Kevin as my mate for kicks. I'd like to see how people react to that. Maybe they'll just think I've adopted Australian slang...
Jun 17, 2009
John said...
Does that 50 bucks have to be paid at a party and not a "wedding"?
Jun 17, 2009
Arianne said...
I'll leave that up to you, John.

Leave a comment...